Following their victory
over the Kuomintang Nationalists in 1949, the Chinese Communist Party
(CCP) sought to re-establish direct control over the traditional
periphery of Qing China. Areas such as Tibet and Xinjiang had,
following the fall of the Qing dynasty in 1911, drifted out of
Beijing’s orbit, achieving de facto independence. In 1950 the
People’s Liberation Army (PLA) retook Tibet for the new central
government in Beijing. This move led to ethnic and religious conflict
as tensions rose between the Buddhist Tibetans and the Han dominated,
officially atheist CCP government. At the centre of Tibetan
resistance was the centuries old link between the people and Tibetan
Buddhism, as personified by the Dalai Lama. The 14th and
current Dalai Lama resisted the Chinese occupation of Tibet, yet
following a failed uprising was forced to flee to India in 1959.
over the Kuomintang Nationalists in 1949, the Chinese Communist Party
(CCP) sought to re-establish direct control over the traditional
periphery of Qing China. Areas such as Tibet and Xinjiang had,
following the fall of the Qing dynasty in 1911, drifted out of
Beijing’s orbit, achieving de facto independence. In 1950 the
People’s Liberation Army (PLA) retook Tibet for the new central
government in Beijing. This move led to ethnic and religious conflict
as tensions rose between the Buddhist Tibetans and the Han dominated,
officially atheist CCP government. At the centre of Tibetan
resistance was the centuries old link between the people and Tibetan
Buddhism, as personified by the Dalai Lama. The 14th and
current Dalai Lama resisted the Chinese occupation of Tibet, yet
following a failed uprising was forced to flee to India in 1959.
| Coronation of the Dalai Lama, March 17th 1950 Photo Credit: tibetanaltar.blogspot.ca |
The Tibetan government
in exile still resides in India as does a large Tibetan diaspora. Since 1959 the Dalai Lama has become globally renowned,
earning the Nobel Peace Prize in 1989 – much to the chagrin of
Beijing – especially given the timing of the award which was most
likely heavily influenced by China’s actions during the Tiananmen
Square protests in the same year. Having defied every leader of
modern China since Mao, the Dalai Lama has in sense become China’s
Castro: an initially threatening, later perennially just out of
reach, half-century old thorn-in-the-side, frustratingly enjoying
international support, and achieving mythic levels of intransigence
thanks primarily to China’s hyperbolic rhetoric. Just switch out
Beijing for Washington, and you have the Castro regime: both even came to international attention in 1959.
in exile still resides in India as does a large Tibetan diaspora. Since 1959 the Dalai Lama has become globally renowned,
earning the Nobel Peace Prize in 1989 – much to the chagrin of
Beijing – especially given the timing of the award which was most
likely heavily influenced by China’s actions during the Tiananmen
Square protests in the same year. Having defied every leader of
modern China since Mao, the Dalai Lama has in sense become China’s
Castro: an initially threatening, later perennially just out of
reach, half-century old thorn-in-the-side, frustratingly enjoying
international support, and achieving mythic levels of intransigence
thanks primarily to China’s hyperbolic rhetoric. Just switch out
Beijing for Washington, and you have the Castro regime: both even came to international attention in 1959.
Amusing digressions
aside, the Dalai Lama continues to head China’s dissident list, with
Beijing regularly exercising pressure at the international level to
inhibit his movements and counter his popularity. If not acceding to
China’s ‘One China’ rule is the paramount deal breaker when engaging
with the regime in Beijing; a ‘One Tibet’ – not parlaying with the
Dalai Lama – rule is not far behind. While countries such as the
United States publicly embrace the Dalai Lama at regular intervals
whenever they need to tweak China’ nose, smaller nations with less
geo-political clout often cannot. For instance, on September 4th
South Africa denied the Dalai Lama a visa to visit the country. This
was the third such denial in five years, with this most recent
refusal preventing the Dalai Lama from attending the 14th
world summit of Nobel Peace Prize laureates. The level of irony
inherent in South Africa’s actions is almost farcical, especially
given the recent passing of Nelson Mandela: the country’s own Nobel
Prize winning leader who fought for an oppressed people, and was
repeatedly denied entry into various countries.
aside, the Dalai Lama continues to head China’s dissident list, with
Beijing regularly exercising pressure at the international level to
inhibit his movements and counter his popularity. If not acceding to
China’s ‘One China’ rule is the paramount deal breaker when engaging
with the regime in Beijing; a ‘One Tibet’ – not parlaying with the
Dalai Lama – rule is not far behind. While countries such as the
United States publicly embrace the Dalai Lama at regular intervals
whenever they need to tweak China’ nose, smaller nations with less
geo-political clout often cannot. For instance, on September 4th
South Africa denied the Dalai Lama a visa to visit the country. This
was the third such denial in five years, with this most recent
refusal preventing the Dalai Lama from attending the 14th
world summit of Nobel Peace Prize laureates. The level of irony
inherent in South Africa’s actions is almost farcical, especially
given the recent passing of Nelson Mandela: the country’s own Nobel
Prize winning leader who fought for an oppressed people, and was
repeatedly denied entry into various countries.
| The Dalai Lama Arrives in India Photo Credit: Indian Defence Review |
While the actions of
the South African government seem arbitrary, Pretoria has more to
lose from angering China than from being a hypocrite. South Africa is
China’s largest trade partner in Africa, with trade increasing by
thirty-two percent since 2012, reaching $25 billion in 2013.
Furthermore, while trade with South Africa only equals four percent
of China’s trade with the EU, China is South Africa’s biggest export
and import partner, comprising 14.5 and 14.9 percent of Pretoria’s trade, respectively. Consequently, South Africa needs to placate
China via acts such as denying entry to the Dalai Lama; a move that did not go
unnoticed. According to Xinhua, the Chinese Foreign Ministry
spokesperson Qin Gang stated that China “greatly appreciates”
South Africa’s efforts, in preventing access to a dangerous separatist.
the South African government seem arbitrary, Pretoria has more to
lose from angering China than from being a hypocrite. South Africa is
China’s largest trade partner in Africa, with trade increasing by
thirty-two percent since 2012, reaching $25 billion in 2013.
Furthermore, while trade with South Africa only equals four percent
of China’s trade with the EU, China is South Africa’s biggest export
and import partner, comprising 14.5 and 14.9 percent of Pretoria’s trade, respectively. Consequently, South Africa needs to placate
China via acts such as denying entry to the Dalai Lama; a move that did not go
unnoticed. According to Xinhua, the Chinese Foreign Ministry
spokesperson Qin Gang stated that China “greatly appreciates”
South Africa’s efforts, in preventing access to a dangerous separatist.
Interestingly, Xinhua
goes on to state that the Dalai was simply prevented from attending a
meeting in South Africa. By excluding any mention of the nature of
said meeting – an assemblage of Peace Prize winners – Xinhua
seeks to erode any moral high ground that the Dalai Lama could occupy
as a result of South Africa’s actions. Excising mention of the Nobel
Peace Prize firstly seek to downplay the international recognition of
the Tibetan cause, and secondly sow confusion and suspicion among
Xinhua’s readership as to the nature and intent of said meeting.
goes on to state that the Dalai was simply prevented from attending a
meeting in South Africa. By excluding any mention of the nature of
said meeting – an assemblage of Peace Prize winners – Xinhua
seeks to erode any moral high ground that the Dalai Lama could occupy
as a result of South Africa’s actions. Excising mention of the Nobel
Peace Prize firstly seek to downplay the international recognition of
the Tibetan cause, and secondly sow confusion and suspicion among
Xinhua’s readership as to the nature and intent of said meeting.
China’s efforts to
curtail the Dalai Lama’s freedom of movement and international
support is premised on the assertion that he embodies a dangerous
separatist movement as well as heading a government in exile. Not
only is the Dalai Lama not the head of the government, having
fostered the creation of a democratic regime in exile since the 1960s,
he also officially devolved himself from the political leadership in 2011, claiming the time for a new leader. Paradoxically it is the
Chinese government that has become the chief voice
emphasizing the importance of the Dalai Lama on the world stage.
curtail the Dalai Lama’s freedom of movement and international
support is premised on the assertion that he embodies a dangerous
separatist movement as well as heading a government in exile. Not
only is the Dalai Lama not the head of the government, having
fostered the creation of a democratic regime in exile since the 1960s,
he also officially devolved himself from the political leadership in 2011, claiming the time for a new leader. Paradoxically it is the
Chinese government that has become the chief voice
emphasizing the importance of the Dalai Lama on the world stage.
| No Successor Needed, Position of Dalai Lama has Served Its Purpose Photo Credit: Die Welt am Sonntag |
While he is revered and
respected by many Tibetans and non-Tibetans alike, efforts to
re-establish Tibetan self-rule are focused on achieving democratic,
not theocratic governance. The Dalai Lama himself acknowledges this
and in a recent interview in German newspaper Die Welt am Sonntag,
stated that he does not wish for a successor. Officially retired
since 2011, the Dalai Lama stated that he did not want officials to
appoint a successor after his death, arguing that the
450 year old tradition had served its purpose. Furthermore, during
the interview he highlighted the large and effective network of
Buddhist monks and scholars, stating that Tibetan Buddhism was not dependent on or dictated by one person. This statement is
primarily a simple acknowledgment of the work of the Tibetan
community, as well as characteristic humility, yet it also sends a
strong message to China that the struggle over Tibet does not start
or end with the Dalai Lama.
respected by many Tibetans and non-Tibetans alike, efforts to
re-establish Tibetan self-rule are focused on achieving democratic,
not theocratic governance. The Dalai Lama himself acknowledges this
and in a recent interview in German newspaper Die Welt am Sonntag,
stated that he does not wish for a successor. Officially retired
since 2011, the Dalai Lama stated that he did not want officials to
appoint a successor after his death, arguing that the
450 year old tradition had served its purpose. Furthermore, during
the interview he highlighted the large and effective network of
Buddhist monks and scholars, stating that Tibetan Buddhism was not dependent on or dictated by one person. This statement is
primarily a simple acknowledgment of the work of the Tibetan
community, as well as characteristic humility, yet it also sends a
strong message to China that the struggle over Tibet does not start
or end with the Dalai Lama.
| Xi Jinping Speaks in Paris, March 2014 |
The
seventy-nine year old Lama also expressed his firm belief that
he will eventually be able to return to Tibet. According to
assessments of the Dalai Lama’s health, doctors have stated that he
will likely live to be one hundred, with the Dalai Lama himself
stating that in his dreams he sees himself dying at the age of 113. Such potential longevity adds two to three decades onto the Dalai
Lama’s perspective, in turn making him confident about not only his
chances of returning to Tibet, but of China’s gradual
democratization. If such a perspective seems naïve, one need only
look at the difference that 20-30 years has already made in China
with regards to civil society and personal freedoms. The Dalai Lama
told Die Welt am Sonntag
that China must and will democratize as it can no longer choose
isolation nor inoculate itself against globalizing influences.
seventy-nine year old Lama also expressed his firm belief that
he will eventually be able to return to Tibet. According to
assessments of the Dalai Lama’s health, doctors have stated that he
will likely live to be one hundred, with the Dalai Lama himself
stating that in his dreams he sees himself dying at the age of 113. Such potential longevity adds two to three decades onto the Dalai
Lama’s perspective, in turn making him confident about not only his
chances of returning to Tibet, but of China’s gradual
democratization. If such a perspective seems naïve, one need only
look at the difference that 20-30 years has already made in China
with regards to civil society and personal freedoms. The Dalai Lama
told Die Welt am Sonntag
that China must and will democratize as it can no longer choose
isolation nor inoculate itself against globalizing influences.
Interestingly, despite continuing opposition from Beijing, the Dalai Lama expressed his admiration for current Chinese President Xi Jinping, citing Xi’s efforts to continue along the path of Hu Jintao’s
harmonious society, as well as his anti-corruption stance which has caused Xi to make many enemies among the CCP’s old guard.
Lastly, the Dalai Lama argued that he sees these actions as indicative of
China’s progress toward slowly becoming more open and inclusive; a
view buttressed by Xi’s March 2014 statement in Paris crediting
Buddhism with playing an important part in the development of Chinese
civilization.
harmonious society, as well as his anti-corruption stance which has caused Xi to make many enemies among the CCP’s old guard.
Lastly, the Dalai Lama argued that he sees these actions as indicative of
China’s progress toward slowly becoming more open and inclusive; a
view buttressed by Xi’s March 2014 statement in Paris crediting
Buddhism with playing an important part in the development of Chinese
civilization.
